A custom tile shower is one of the biggest upgrades you can make to a bathroom. It looks better than a prefab unit, it adds real value to your home, and a well-built one lasts for decades. But the tile you see is only the surface. What makes a shower last — or fail — is the work underneath it, and that work is done by the person you hire.
Choosing the right installer matters more than choosing the right tile. Here is what to look for, what to ask, and what to watch out for when you hire someone to build a custom tile shower in Evansville.
1. Ask How They Waterproof
This is the single most important question you can ask, and the answer tells you almost everything about an installer. Tile and grout are not waterproof. Water passes through them every time you shower. What keeps a shower dry is the waterproof membrane underneath — on the walls, under the floor, sealed at every corner, seam, and drain connection. Ask any installer, in plain words: "How do you waterproof the shower?" A good installer will explain their system clearly. If the answer is vague, or if they say the tile itself keeps the water out, walk away.
2. Ask How Long the Job Takes — and Why
A custom tile shower takes about a week to build properly. Each layer has to cure before the next one goes on: the waterproofing, the thinset under the tile, the grout. Rushing any of those steps is how grout cracks and tiles loosen. If someone promises a full custom tile shower in two or three days, ask what they are skipping. At River City Flooring Pros, a standard custom tile shower takes about a week from tear-out to final grout, and costs $7,000-$8,000.
3. Ask to See Their Recent Shower Work
Photos of finished showers are a start, but ask for more than the glamour shots. Ask for photos taken during the job — the waterproofing going on, the tile being set, the floor sloping toward the drain. An installer who is proud of the hidden work will have those photos. Better yet, ask if they have a recent customer in Evansville you can talk to.
4. Make Sure the Price Is Written Down
A custom tile shower is a $7,000-$8,000 investment. Before any work starts, you should have a written estimate that says what is included: tear-out of the old shower, waterproofing, tile, grout, niche, bench, fixtures, and cleanup. If the price is only spoken, or if the estimate is a single number with no breakdown, you have no way to know what you are actually paying for.
5. Check That the Details Are Planned Before Work Starts
A good tile shower is planned, not improvised. Before framing begins, your installer should know where the niche goes, how big the bench is, where the shower head and controls sit, and how the tile pattern runs on each wall. Details decided after the walls are up end up in the wrong place. Walk through the plan with your installer before the first tile is cut.
6. Look for a Local Installer Who Stands Behind the Work
A tile shower should last decades. That means the installer should still be around — and still answering the phone — if something ever needs attention. A local Evansville installer who lives and works in the community has a reputation to protect on every job. Ask what happens if a grout line cracks or a tile loosens a year from now. A straight answer is a good sign. A shrug is not.
7. Trust Your Gut on Communication
From the first call to the final walkthrough, pay attention to how the installer communicates. Do they return your calls? Do they explain things in plain English? Do they listen to what you actually want? A shower remodel means a crew in your bathroom for a week. You want someone who treats your home with respect, keeps the work area clean, and keeps you updated as the job moves along.
The Bottom Line
The tile you pick matters. The fixtures matter. The niche, the bench, the glass — they all matter. But none of it matters as much as the person building the shower. Waterproofing, drainage, curing times, planning — all of it comes down to the installer doing the hidden work right. So take your time choosing. Ask the waterproofing question. Ask for the photos. Get the estimate in writing. And hire someone local who will still be here when you need them.
If you are planning a custom tile shower in Evansville, River City Flooring Pros would love to talk it through with you. We build one shower at a time, about a week per shower, for $7,000-$8,000 — waterproofed right, tiled straight, and built to last. Call (812) 454-1631 for a free estimate. We will walk through your bathroom, talk about what you want, and give you a clear written price before any work begins.
